Sarang V. Kotwal, J
1. Heard Mr. Ashish Jha, learned counsel for the Petitioner and Mr. Vinod Chate, learned APP for the Respondent â€" State.
2. This Writ Petition is already admitted. By consent of the parties, it is taken up for final hearing. Learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that
the Petitioner is a young Engineer and he proposes to study abroad for further education. Considering his future, we have heard the Petition finally
which was already admitted vide order dated 1.10.2024.
3. This Petition is for quashing and setting aside the proceedings pending before the J.M.F.C., Vasai vide S.C.C. No.548/2021 under Section 8(c) read
with 27 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for short, the N.D.P.S. Act). The prosecution case is reflected in the FIR
lodged by Shri Kiran Avhad, Police Constable attached to Manikpur police station. The FIR is lodged at the said police station vide C.R. No.II-
36/2021 dated 7.2.2021. It is mentioned in the FIR that the informant and his team had received instructions from their superiors to conduct raid within
jurisdiction of their police station against the persons who were consuming narcotic drugs. The informant’s team called two panchas. They started
patrolling in that area in civil dress. At about 7.00 p.m. on 7.2.2021 they came near Sun City. They received secret information that two persons were
consuming narcotic drug in an open place in front of a temple.
The informant’s team went there. It is the case of the prosecution that two persons took out something from their bag and kept that substance in
their pipe and started smoking. The informant’s team was convinced that those two persons were smoking Ganja. They encircled those two
persons. The FIR does not mention as to what happened to the second person. The present Petitioner was apprehended. According to the first
informant his eyes did not look normal and his fingers and nails had blackish tinge. When they asked the Petitioner as to what he was doing, he told
them that he was smoking Ganja. Interestingly the FIR further mentions that the informant’s team destroyed the pipe, the substance which was
with the Petitioner which the informant describes as tobacco mixed Ganja, match box and burnt match sticks. All the articles were destroyed. They
gave an option to the Petitioner to take him to the nearest Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer for his personal search. He declined the offer. The raiding
party then conducted his personal search. Nothing objectionable was found on his person. He was arrested and was sent for medical examination at
D.N. Petit Hospital, Parnaka, Vasai West. On this basis, the FIR is lodged.
4. Learned counsel for the Petitioner invited our attention to the investigation reflected in the charge-sheet. He submitted that there is nothing to show
that the Petitioner was smoking Ganja. The statement made by him before the police officer is not admissible. Therefore, the investigating agency had
to establish, at least prima facie that the Petitioner was smoking Ganja then only they could have filed the charge-sheet. In the present case, there is
absolutely nothing to show that the Petitioner was smoking Ganja or was in possession of Ganja. Nothing was seized. As admitted by the first
informant, the articles were destroyed at the spot itself. Therefore, there is no incriminating material against the present Petitioner.
5. Learned APP relied on the allegations made in the FIR and other documents in the charge-sheet to oppose these submissions.
6. We have considered these submissions and we have perused the charge-sheet annexed to this Petition. The charge-sheet contains the panchnama
signed by the two panchas. It is the exact replica of the allegations in the FIR. There is a statement of the other team member, namely, Police Nayak
Kalpesh Keni. Even his statement is exactly the same. Beyond that, there is absolutely nothing in the entire charge-sheet. Since the seized articles
were already destroyed, there is no question of getting FSL report to prove or even to indicate that the Petitioner was smoking Ganja. There was no
reference as to what happened to the other person. Therefore, it is quite clear that there is no material against the Petitioner. However, he was
needlessly prosecuted and is unnecessarily suffering from 2021.
7. The entire investigation is extremely doubtful and suspicious. Apart from that, no offence is made out against the Petitioner in the entire charge-
sheet. Continuation of the proceedings would be an abuse of process of law. There are absolutely no chances of conviction in this case. Therefore,
the Petition deserves to succeed.
8. Hence, the following order:
::ORDER::
i. The FIR registered vide C.R. No.II-36/2021 dated 7.2.2021 registered at Manikpur Police Station, District Palghar as well as the criminal
proceedings being S.C.C. No.548/2021 pending before the J.M.F.C.. Vasai, are quashed and set aside.
ii. The Petition is disposed of accordingly.
