Mukhtiar Vs Ram Kumar and Others

High Court Of Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh 20 Sep 2010 C.R. No. 3246 of 2010 (2010) 09 P&H CK 0316
Bench: Single Bench
Result Published

Judgement Snapshot

Case Number

C.R. No. 3246 of 2010

Hon'ble Bench

Alok Singh, J

Final Decision

Dismissed

Judgement Text

Translate:

Alok Singh, J.@mdashPresent petition is filed challenging order dated 29.4.2010 passed by Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.) Narnaul thereby transposing the proforma defendants as plaintiffs.

2. The brief facts of the present case are that plaintiff has filed suit for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the contesting defendants from interfering in the suit land. The main ground taken in the plaint is that plaintiff in the suit is co-owner alongwith proforma defendants and they have purchased the land in dispute from defendants Nos. 1 to 5 and their predecessor-in-interest Smt. Sarya widow of Bullu. Contesting defendants preferred the counter claim in the suit. Suit of the plaintiff was directed to be dismissed in default vide order dated 17.8.2007, however, counter claim was directed to proceed. Thereafter, proforma defendants having interest with the plaintiff moved an application before the Court for transposing them as the plaintiff in the suit. Learned trial Court, having observed that since the proforma defendants are claiming themselves as co-owner with the plaintiff and relief sought in the counter claim is against the plaintiff as well as proforma defendants, hence, to contest counter claim effectively proforma defendants should be transposed as plaintiff, directed transposition of proforma defendants as plaintiffs.

3. I find no illegality or jurisdictional error in the order impugned.

4. Petition is dismissed.

From The Blog
Supreme Court Rules: Tenants Cannot Claim Ownership of Rented Property, Big Relief for Landlords
Dec
21
2025

Court News

Supreme Court Rules: Tenants Cannot Claim Ownership of Rented Property, Big Relief for Landlords
Read More
Punjab & Haryana High Court Rejects Realtor’s Plea: Signatures Only on Last Page Raise Fraud Concerns in 2007 Land Deal
Dec
21
2025

Court News

Punjab & Haryana High Court Rejects Realtor’s Plea: Signatures Only on Last Page Raise Fraud Concerns in 2007 Land Deal
Read More