NIC Vs AVTAR SINGH

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION 16 Oct 1997 (1997) 10 NCDRC CK 0010
Result Published

Judgement Snapshot

Hon'ble Bench

P.N.Nag , I.D.Bali , Krishana Tandon J.

Final Decision

Application dismissed

Judgement Text

Translate:

1. BY this application, the applicant/appellant wants to lead additional evidence under Order 18, Rule 17, C.P.C. to demonstrate that the driving licence was forged.



2. MR. L.C. Kapoor, learned Counsel for the applicant/appellant has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in a case Natha Singh & Ors. v. The Financial Commissioner, Taxation, Punjab & Ors., AIR 1976 SC 1053.

At the very outset, it may be pointed out that this authority refers to Order 41, Rule 27, C.P.C. and not Order 18, Rule 17, C.P.C. At any rate, the principle laid down by the Hon''ble Supreme Court is that the true test to be applied in dealing with applications for additional evidence is whether the Appellate Court is able to pronounce judgment on the materials before it, without taking into consideration the additional evidence sought to be adduced.

On the basis of the evidence produced by the parties before the District Forum, we find no difficulty in pronouncing the judgment on such material and as such, no additional evidence can be permitted. In fact, to us, this application of the applicant/appellant seems to be angrier-thought and intended to fill up the lacuna at this belated stage, which cannot be permitted. The application is wholly misconceived and is dismissed. Application dismissed.

From The Blog
J&K High Court: Dealer and Manufacturer Jointly Liable for Car Defects Reported Within Warranty Period
Dec
08
2025

Court News

J&K High Court: Dealer and Manufacturer Jointly Liable for Car Defects Reported Within Warranty Period
Read More
ITAT Ahmedabad: Assessment Order Invalid Without DVO Report, Property Valuation Additions Quashed
Dec
08
2025

Court News

ITAT Ahmedabad: Assessment Order Invalid Without DVO Report, Property Valuation Additions Quashed
Read More