Dinabandhu Mandal Vs Paschim Banga Gramin Bank & Ors

Calcutta High Court 6 Sep 2019 Writ Petitions (WP) No. 11850 (W) Of 2013 (2019) 09 CAL CK 0022
Bench: Single Bench
Result Published
Acts Referenced

Judgement Snapshot

Case Number

Writ Petitions (WP) No. 11850 (W) Of 2013

Hon'ble Bench

Md. Nizamuddin, J

Advocates

Debabarata Saha Roy, Indranil Mitra, Subhankar Das, Neil Basu, C.R. Bakshi

Final Decision

Dismissed

Acts Referred
  • Howrah Gramin Bank Staff Service Regulations, 2000 - Rule 38
  • Constitution Of India, 1950 - Article 136

Judgement Text

Translate:

Sl No.,"Name & Address of

the borrower","Limit sanctioned/d

isbursed (Rs.) and dated","Loan A/c

No.",Nature of Security,Mode of disbursement

1.,"Sri Prasanta Roy

i)P25, C.I.T. Road,

Kolkata- 10 ii)35,

Kashinath Chatterjee

Lane, Sibpur,

Howrah-2","4,70,250/- dated

19.03.2002",KVP-08,"KVP Nos. 35BB

929901 to 35BB

929942 and 35BB

929944 to 35BB

930000 of Rs.

5000/- each",Paid in Cash

2.,"Sri Prasanta Roy

i)P25, C.I.T. Road,

Kolkata- 10 ii)35,

Kashinath Chatterjee

Lane, Sibpur,

Howrah-2","2,13,750/- dated

19.03.2002",KVP-09,"KVP Nos. 35BB

929801 to 35BB

929845 of Rs.5000/-

each. Total amount

Rs. 2,25,000/- Regd.

No. 722 dated

12.02.99",Paid in Cash

3.,"Sri Prasanta Roy

i)P25, C.I.T. Road,

Kolkata- 10 ii)35,

Kashinath Chatterjee

Lane, Sibpur,

Howrah-2","4,75,000/- dated

13.04.2002",KVP-10,"KVP Nos. 35BB

958901 to 35BB

95900 of Rs.5000/-

each. Total amount

Rs. 5,00,000/- Regd.

No. 280 dated

30.06.99",Paid in Cash

4.,"Sri Prasanta Roy

i)P25, C.I.T. Road,

Kolkata- 10 ii)35,

Kashinath Chatterjee

Lane, Sibpur,

Howrah-2","4,75,000/- dated

13.04.2002",KVP-11,"KVP Nos. 35BB

958401 to 35BB9

58500 of Rs.5000/-

each. Total amount

Rs. 5,00,000/- Regd.

No. 282 dated

01.07.99",Paid in Cash

Charge No.,Findings of DA,Penalty(ies) awarded by DA,"Order of the

Appellate Authority",,

Charge No.1,Proved,"Reduction from Middle

Management Grade ScaleII to

Junior Management Grade

Scale-I with basic salary being

fixed at Rs. 18,240/-. Next

increment to Sri Mondal shall

fall due one year after date of

this order subject to usual

service conditions.","Reduction from

Middle Management

Grade ScaleII to

Junior Management

Grade Scale-I with

basic salary being

fixed at Rs. 18,240/-.

Next increment to Sri

Mandal shall fall due

one year after date of

this order subject to

usual service

conditions.",,

Charge No.2,Proved,"Reduction from Middle

Management Grade ScaleII to

Junior Management Grade

Scale-I with basic salary being

fixed at Rs. 18,240/-. Next

increment to Sri Mondal shall

fall due one year after date of

this order subject to usual

service conditions.","Reduction from

Middle Management

Grade ScaleII to

Junior Management

Grade Scale-I with

basic salary being

fixed at Rs. 18,240/-.

Next increment to Sri

Mondal shall fall due

one year after date of

this order subject to

usual service

conditions",,

Charge No.3,Proved,"Sri Mandal would be debarred

from taking part in any

promotion process which starts

on or before 31.12.2009.","Sri Mandal would be

debarred from taking

part in any promotion

process which starts

on or before

31.12.2009.",,

Charge No.

4",Proved,"Recovery of the sum of Rs.

16,34,000/- (Rs. Sixteen lac

thirty four thousand only)

which is the pecuniary loss

caused to the Bank, in

instalments of Rs. 8000/-

(Rupees Eight thousand only)

from his monthly emoluments

or from such other amounts as

may be due to him from the

Bank. Residual amount, if any,

remaining unrecovered from

the terminal benefits of Sri

Mandal.","Recovery of the sum

of Rs. 16,34,000/-

(Rs. Sixteen lac thirty

four thousand only)

which is the

pecuniary loss caused

to the Bank, in

instalments of Rs.

8000/- (Rupees Eight

thousand only) from

his monthly

emoluments or from

such other amounts

as may be due to him

from the Bank.

Residual amount, if

any, remaining

unrecovered from the

terminal benefits of

Sri Mandal.",,

Charge No.

5",Proved,"Recovery of the sum of Rs.

16,34,000/- (Rs. Sixteen lac

thirty four thousand only)

which is the pecuniary loss

caused to the Bank, in

instalments of Rs. 8000/- (Rs.

Eight thousand only) from his

monthly emoluments or from

such other amounts as may be

due to him from the Bank.

Residual amount, if any,

remaining unrecovered from

the terminal benefits of Sri

Mandal.","Recovery of the sum

of Rs. 16,34,000/-

(Rs. Sixteen lac thirty

four thousand only)

which is the

pecuniary loss caused

to the Bank, in

instalments of Rs.

8000/- (Rs. Eight

thousand only) from

his monthly

emoluments or from

such other amounts

as may be due to him

from the Bank.

Residual amount, if

any, remaining

unrecovered from the

terminal benefits of

Sri Mandal.",,

From The Blog
Madras High Court to Hear School’s Plea Against State Objection to RSS Camp on Campus
Feb
07
2026

Court News

Madras High Court to Hear School’s Plea Against State Objection to RSS Camp on Campus
Read More
Delhi High Court Quashes Ban on Medical Students’ Inter-College Migration, Calls Rule Arbitrary
Feb
07
2026

Court News

Delhi High Court Quashes Ban on Medical Students’ Inter-College Migration, Calls Rule Arbitrary
Read More