Central Bank of India Vs Saroop Singh

High Court Of Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh 3 Feb 2014 RSA No. 578 of 2014 (O and M) (2014) 02 P&H CK 0099
Bench: Single Bench

Judgement Snapshot

Case Number

RSA No. 578 of 2014 (O and M)

Hon'ble Bench

Rakesh Kumar Jain, J

Advocates

Rajesh Mahajan, Advocate for the Appellant

Judgement Text

Translate:

Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.@mdashThe defendant is in appeal against the judgment and decree of both the Courts below whereby suit filed by the plaintiff for possession by way of ejectment from the demised premises has been decreed. In brief, the plaintiff sought eviction of the defendants from the building, having carpet area of 960 sq. ft. bearing Khewat No. 493, Khatauni No. 773, Khasra No. 483 (0-6), situated in the revenue estate of village Lakhewali, Tehsil Sri Muktsar Sahib. A lease deed was executed between the parties on 26.09.2005 and the rate of rent of the demised premises was fixed @ Rs. 3,000/- per month. The lease was executed for 5 years and it was provided therein that in case the lessee wanted to continue with the lease after the 5 years'' term is over w.e.f. 01.06.2010, he would at least give 30 days prior notice before 31.05.2010 or earlier, indicating his desire and shall pay the rent as stipulated therein. The lease expired on 01.06.2010 but the defendants did not give one month''s notice in writing prior to the lapse of time of lease deed. Thus, it was alleged that the defendants were in unauthorized possession after the expiry of the lease period for which a legal notice for a period of 15 days was given by the plaintiffs on 18.08.2010 to which the defendants gave a vague reply. After the expiry of the notice period, suit for possession by way of eviction was filed.

2. In the written statement, it is alleged that on 01.06.2010, the rent was increased and was credited to the account of the plaintiff after getting proper sanction from the Regional Office. It is alleged that the plaintiffs have been regularly operating their account in which the enhanced rent is being credited, therefore, the defendants were continuing as tenants and could not have been dispossessed by terminating the tenancy by serving a notice.

3. The plaintiffs filed replication and on the basis of the pleadings, issues were framed. Both the parties led their oral as well as documentary evidence in support of their case.

4. The Courts below have found that the tenancy had commenced with the execution of the lease deed and was to expire after 5 years. There was a clear stipulation that if the lessee wanted to continue with the lease, he would give at least 30 days prior notice in writing to the lessor of his intention was to continue and since no notice was given, the tenancy was deemed to have been terminated.

5. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that since the plaintiffs have been accepting the payment of enhanced rent in their account deposited by the bank, therefore, the tenancy was deemed to have been continued but the learned Courts below, while relying upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Shanti Prasad Devi and Another Vs. Shankar Mahto and Others, have held that mere acceptance of rent for the subsequent months, in which, the lessee continued to occupy the lease premises cannot be said to be a conduct signifying "assent" to the continuance of the lessee, even after expiry of lease period.

6. No judgment to the contrary has been cited by the counsel for the appellant. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I do not find any question of law much-less substantial involved in the present appeal and hence, the same is hereby dismissed.

From The Blog
Supreme Court Quashes Bihar’s Mutation Rule: Property Sale Registration Cannot Be Blocked by Extra Conditions
Nov
11
2025

Court News

Supreme Court Quashes Bihar’s Mutation Rule: Property Sale Registration Cannot Be Blocked by Extra Conditions
Read More
How Indians Can Start a Company in the USA: Step-by-Step Guide, Costs, and Legal Requirements
Nov
11
2025

Court News

How Indians Can Start a Company in the USA: Step-by-Step Guide, Costs, and Legal Requirements
Read More