Raman Vs Secretary of State for India in Council

Madras High Court 29 Jan 1901 (1901) 01 MAD CK 0003
Bench: Division Bench
Acts Referenced

Judgement Snapshot

Hon'ble Bench

Arnold White, C.J; Subrahmania Ayyar, J

Acts Referred
  • Suits Valuation Act, 1887 - Section 11

Judgement Text

Translate:

1. It has been objected on behalf of the respondent) that the order of lower Appellate Court remitting the case to the Court of First Instance for a

finding on the issue as to title Was made without jurisdiction and that anything done in pursuance of that order must be treated as a nullity. The

objection is based on undervaluation. In a case like this the effect of Section 11 of the Suits Valuation Act is to cure the want of jurisdiction unless

the Appellate Court is satisfied that the undervaluation has prejudicially affected the cause on the merits. If the lower Appellate Court had finally

disposed of the appeal on the merits, it might be said that the party against whom the decision went had been prejudicially affected, but there has

been no disposal on the merits, and it is open to this Court to deal with the findings and go into the question of their correctness. We are unable to

accept the respondent''s suggestion that Section 11 of the Suits Valuation Act only applies when there is a final disposal by the lower Appellate

Court. The objection must be overruled

From The Blog
Supreme Court Rules: Tenants Cannot Claim Ownership of Rented Property, Big Relief for Landlords
Dec
21
2025

Court News

Supreme Court Rules: Tenants Cannot Claim Ownership of Rented Property, Big Relief for Landlords
Read More
Punjab & Haryana High Court Rejects Realtor’s Plea: Signatures Only on Last Page Raise Fraud Concerns in 2007 Land Deal
Dec
21
2025

Court News

Punjab & Haryana High Court Rejects Realtor’s Plea: Signatures Only on Last Page Raise Fraud Concerns in 2007 Land Deal
Read More