Ram Charan Goldar and Others Vs Hamid Ali and Others

Calcutta High Court 26 Apr 1928 AIR 1929 Cal 575 : 117 Ind. Cas. 595
Bench: Division Bench
Acts Referenced

Judgement Snapshot

Hon'ble Bench

Rankin, C.J

Acts Referred

Court Fees Act, 1870 — Article 11(b), 5

Judgement Text

Translate:

@JUDGMENTTAG-ORDER

Rankin, C.J.@mdashIn this case two learned Judges differed in the decision of a second appeal and in the end Cuming, J., under the amended

letters prevailed and the appeal was dismissed Thereupon an application was made to Patent for a certificate that the case was a fit one to be

taken on further appeal. That application was made subsequently to the learned Judge upon a separate petition. It was rejected and the rejection

was recorded in the order sheet ;

Bead an application filed on 23rd February 1928, and moved to-day. It is rejected.

2. The order is dated 24th February 1928.

3. From that an appeal has been brought and the memorandum of appeal when lodged was excepted to by the stamp reporter on the ground that it

was insufficiently stamped. It does not appear to have been sufficiently stamped, but the question of the correct Court-fee has been referred to me

by the Taxing Officer u/s 5, Court-fees Act.

4. It is contended for the appellant that this case is governed by Article 11(b), Schedule 2 of the Act, which applies to a memorandum of appeal

when the appeal is not an appeal from a decree or an order having the force of a decree. I have examined the decree which has since been drawn

up in the matter of the second appeal and I find in it no reference to the application for leave to appeal. In these circumstances it appears to me that

the Court-fee is chargeable on this memorandum of appeal under Article 11(b), Schedule 2 to the Court-fees Act as has been contended for on

behalf of the appellant.

5. Accordingly the deficit Court-fee will be accepted if put in by Monday next.

From The Blog
Supreme Court: Hindu Succession Act Excludes Tribal Daughters
Oct
22
2025

Story

Supreme Court: Hindu Succession Act Excludes Tribal Daughters
Read More
Supreme Court Alarmed at 8.82 Lakh Pending Execution Cases
Oct
22
2025

Story

Supreme Court Alarmed at 8.82 Lakh Pending Execution Cases
Read More