Debendra Nath Chowdhury and Another Vs The Chairman, Local Board

Calcutta High Court 6 Mar 1924 81 Ind. Cas. 904
Bench: Division Bench
Acts Referenced

Judgement Snapshot

Hon'ble Bench

Panton, J; Greaves, J

Acts Referred

Criminal Procedure Code, 1898 (CrPC) — Section 139A

Judgement Text

Translate:

1. The dispute in this case is between the petitioners and the Local Board. The Local Board''s case was that the petitioners had encroached on

land at the side of a road, which belonged to the Local Board and that as a result of such encroachment the. Local Board drain which ran by the

side of the road had been blocked. Both the Courts have found in favour of the Local Board holding upon the evidence, that the Local Board had

been in possession of the land encroached upon by the petitioners for some 12 years and an order u/s 133 has accordingly been passed.

2. The only question that arises is whether under the circumstances this order was rightly made. It is admitted by both parties who are before us

that according to the Settlement Record, the land alleged to have been encroached on by the petitioners, is the petitioners'' land. Accordingly, the

only question that really arises is whether this is reliable evidence within the meaning of Section 139A of the Code of Criminal Procedure. If it is a

reliable evidence within the meaning of the words of that section then clearly the Criminal Court should have stayed the proceedings and left the

parties to have the matter decided in a Civil Court. In our opinion, once the Settlement Record was produced showing that this land was the

petitioners'' whether that record is right or wrong the Criminal Court should have stayed the proceedings and left the parties to have their rights

decided in a Civil suit.

3. In this view we made the Rule absolute.

Full judgement PDF is available for reference.
Download PDF
From The Blog
Moti Ram Deka & Ors vs General Manager, N.E.F. Railways & Ors (1963)
Oct
19
2025

Landmark Judgements

Moti Ram Deka & Ors vs General Manager, N.E.F. Railways & Ors (1963)
Read More
M/s. Orissa Cement Ltd. & Others vs State of Orissa & Others (1991)
Oct
19
2025

Landmark Judgements

M/s. Orissa Cement Ltd. & Others vs State of Orissa & Others (1991)
Read More