ITAT: Cash Transactions of Co-operative Societies with Members Not Penal If Reasonable Cause Exists
Tribunal deletes penalties under Sections 271D and 271E, citing genuine member transactions
Ruling strengthens protection for co-operative societies engaged in community-based financial dealings
By Our Legal Reporter
New Delhi: January 05, 2026:
In a landmark ruling, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Ahmedabad Bench, has held that cash transactions between a co-operative society and its members cannot be penalized under Sections 271D and 271E of the Income Tax Act if a reasonable cause exists.
Also Read: Karnataka High Court: Custodial Interrogation Not Mandatory in GST Evasion Cases
The Tribunal deleted penalties amounting to over ₹55 crore imposed on a co-operative credit society, clarifying that genuine transactions with members, duly recorded in books of accounts, do not attract punitive provisions. This judgment is expected to have far-reaching implications for thousands of co-operative societies across India.
Background of the Case
- The case involved Shri Umiya Co-operative Credit Society Ltd., which had accepted and repaid cash amounts exceeding ₹20,000 from its members.
- The Assessing Officer levied penalties under Section 271D (acceptance of loans/deposits in cash) and Section 271E (repayment of loans/deposits in cash), totalling nearly ₹55 crore.
- The society argued that all transactions were genuine, member-based, and duly recorded.
- The ITAT upheld the society’s appeal, deleting the penalties.
Court’s Observations
- Transactions Were Genuine
- All cash dealings were with registered members.
- No evidence of unaccounted money or tax evasion was found.
- Reasonable Cause Under Section 273B
- Section 273B provides relief from penalties if the assessee proves a reasonable cause.
- The Tribunal held that member-based transactions constituted a reasonable cause.
- Mutuality Principle
- Co-operative societies operate on the principle of mutuality, where members contribute and benefit collectively.
- Transactions within such societies cannot be equated with commercial violations.
Legal Context
Also Read: J&K High Court: Women Form Distinct Class Under Section 437 CrPC, Bail Granted in Murder Case
- Section 269SS: Prohibits acceptance of loans/deposits above ₹20,000 in cash.
- Section 269T: Prohibits repayment of loans/deposits above ₹20,000 in cash.
- Section 271D & 271E: Prescribe penalties equal to the amount of violation.
- Section 273B: Provides relief if reasonable cause is shown.
Why This Judgment Matters
- Protects Co-operative Societies: Ensures genuine member transactions are not penalized.
- Clarifies Law: Establishes that penalties cannot be imposed mechanically without considering reasonable cause.
- Encourages Community Finance: Strengthens trust in co-operative societies as grassroots financial institutions.
- Reduces Litigation: Provides clarity for tax authorities and societies, reducing disputes.
Wider Impact
- Co-operative Credit Societies: Thousands of societies across India rely on member-based cash transactions.
- Rural Economy: Many rural members lack access to digital banking, making cash dealings inevitable.
- Tax Administration: Authorities must now assess intent and genuineness before imposing penalties.
- Legal Precedent: Strengthens jurisprudence on balancing compliance with practical realities.
Expert Views
Tax experts welcomed the ruling, noting that:
- It prevents harsh penalties on community-based institutions.
- It recognizes the unique nature of co-operative societies.
- It reinforces the principle that law must balance enforcement with fairness.
Also Read: Bombay High Court Bars Restaurants from Playing Copyrighted Songs Without License
Conclusion
The ITAT’s ruling that cash transactions of co-operative societies with members are not penal if reasonable cause exists is a milestone in tax jurisprudence. By deleting penalties under Sections 271D and 271E, the Tribunal reaffirmed that genuine member-based transactions cannot be treated as violations.
This judgment strengthens the position of co-operative societies, protects rural financial practices, and ensures that tax law is applied with fairness and practicality.
GEO-Friendly Keywords
- ITAT ruling cash transactions co-operative society
- Section 271D 271E penalties deleted ITAT
- Reasonable cause Section 273B co-operative society
- Cash loans deposits co-operative credit society India
- ITAT Ahmedabad co-operative society tax ruling
- Section 269SS 269T cash transaction law India
- Co-operative society member transactions tax penalty relief
- Mutuality principle co-operative society ITAT ruling
- Income Tax Act penalties co-operative societies India
Also Read: Supreme Court Denies Bail to Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam in Delhi Riots Case